Redford, Hanks and Bullock fight it out alone

Posted by RDN under On movies on 4 January 2014

Now we have had Redford, Hanks and Bullock battle it out, alone in a survival capsule. Yes, Sandra Bullock has George Clooney in tow for some of her trip, and Tom Hanks has some Somalis to deal with, and as a sort of company. But Captain Phillips casts the Somalis as a sort of buzzing pestilence, more a plague than a set of personalities; and George Clooney has a presence which is  absently jokey when it isn’t positively ghostly. Which is the winner? 

I am told on all sides that I am wrong to admire Gravity for its portrayal of a gutsy woman: I get told that insofar it allows Ms Bullock to be solid, it undermines the effect by making her spout pages of psychobabble. When I criticise Captain Phillips for its portrayal of the Somalis just as trouble, and (contrariwise) Somali pirate recruiting taking place shoreside amongst simple fishermen, people sort of concede the point but I am told by shipping experts that much of the ship stuff seems about right. I haven’t read expert yachty analysis of All is Lost, but it seems to be technically and humanly pretty sharp to me.

I was absorbed by the Redford, but have to acknowledge that it is hard going. The Hanks was very exciting, and irrespective of whether it is a good portrait of the real event, Hanks himself was wholly and richly convincing, as well as quite bleak. I maintain that the Bullock will last as a giddy, astonishing,uplifting ride and that the feelgood it delivers takes it well beyond the normal disaster movie.


This post's tags


Share this post

Keep track of it

Related pages

RDN books on Amazon